Saturday, February 26, 2022

Better Than a Dream

Psalm 126
Transfiguration / Mardi Gras Sunday

 

When the Lord restored the fortunes of Zion, we were like those who dream.

Then our mouth was filled with laughter, and our tongue with shouts of joy;

then it was said among the nations, “The Lord has done great things for them.”

The Lord has done great things for us, and we rejoiced.

 

Restore our fortunes, O Lord, like the watercourses in the Negeb.

May those who sow in tears reap with shouts of joy.

Those who go out weeping, bearing the seed for sowing,

shall come home with shouts of joy, carrying their sheaves.



I thought that I would speak today about joy. And then this past week happened, and I knew I needed to talk about joy.

Yes, it’s a strange and unexpected word. We are two weeks into a pandemic. There are glimmers of reprieve, but we have endured so many diminishments. There are fewer of you here. The big choir has reduced to an octet. People have quit their jobs, moved around. Some have caught a cab to eternity. And I want to talk about joy.

A northeastern Pennsylvania winter crawls along. The clouds brood over us, the sky is dark. No telling when the ice will fall and crust over the driveway. And no one over the age of eighteen is thrilled, to exclaim, “It looks like another snow day!” Even them, who have had twenty-four months of snow days. And believe me when I say it’s a good moment for a few words about joy.

Not merely because the jazz cats are here; it’s always good to see them. They revive our weary souls. The harmonies sneak into our souls. Our feet set off in rhythm. For the old-timers among us, the walls may swinge like the Hot Club of Paris in 1940: everybody sways to the beat while foreign tanks are intent on destruction. And in that disturbing paradox, the musicians play on with joy. Joy.

Maybe it’s getting clear for us that joy is not the same thing as happiness. We frequently tangle them so tightly that they seem like one and the same. She’s happy. He’s joyful. Sounds like the same thing, but it isn’t. Both are emotions, frequently associated with good feelings and a positive spirit.

Happiness is situational; something happens, it makes you happy. You connect with the love of your life, and your happiness soars off the scale. Your wrestling team wins a state championship (Hooray for Abington Heights!), and everybody cheers. The drummer throws in a little backbeat with the hymns and the air is lighter. There’s happiness here, just what we need as an alternative to lingering illness, winter gloom, and a terrible, no-good invasion in Ukraine. Perhaps for a brief time, this hour will counter-balance all the bad news. We can use a little happiness.

By contrast, joy is not created by our circumstances. Joy propels us through our circumstances. Why do we get out of the bed on a morning like this? Not because we are happy, but because joy is quietly at work even when we can’t see it.

The psalm for today declares how joy can surprise us. The poet remembers a national change of events, the winning of a battle or the turn-around of fortunes. “It was like a dream,” he says. “We started to laugh. We shouted hosannas. We laughed even louder – and all the world said, ‘Wow, look how things have turned out for them!’ What a joyful noise we made. Remember that? Can you remember that? Yes, I think we can.”

Then he pauses. Clears his throat for another paragraph. Waits for a bit. And then he says, “Wouldn’t it be great if God could do it again? Wouldn’t it be spectacular if God could sweep up all the broken glass and fuse it into something beautiful? Wouldn’t it be wonderful if God would do now what God had done then?” And twice in this reflection, the poet calls us again to joy. Because joy has caused him to remember. And joy has provoked him to hope. That’s how joy works.

You can think of it this way:

  • Happiness comes when the stars align. Joy keeps us going through a dark, starless night.
  • Happiness visits when all is going well. Joy tarries when they aren’t.
  • Happiness is a car with well-aligned tires. Joy is the engine that keeps the car moving.
  • Happiness bubbles up in us. Joy is an invisible gift from God’s Holy Spirit.

A few years back, Yale University got the John Templeton Foundation to cough up $4.2 million to study joy. The study team brought together psychologists, theologians, Bible scholars, thinkers of all kinds, all to explore the mystery of joy. There were explorations, research projects, speeches, and heavy papers. When the dust settled, they concluded that joy is what causes the human being to flourish. What makes for a well-lived life? It’s the presence of joy.

I thought of this, when my wife got up one morning and called out, “Alexa, play Motown!” The next song we heard was a now-ancient Stevie Wonder tune, titled, “Joy Inside My Tears.” Little Stevie sings his experience how another's love for him has created healing. He is astonished to discover a greater power at work. Amid pain, alienation, and fear, joy has found him. What a powerful, surprising gift!

This is the domain of the Holy Spirit, especially in our own constricted circumstances. Sometimes joy bubbles up in the affirmation that we are worthy of sound mind and good health. Other times joy discovers us when God makes good on a holy promise. Sometimes, it is love that sparks joy. Other times, joy sparks love. And when pushed against the wall, joy shakes its fist as a protest against despair,

That’s how joy can bubble up into the worst circumstances. Remember the apostle Paul, banging his tin cup against the iron bars of his prison cell, and shouting, "Rejoice in the Lord always; again, I say rejoice!" (Philippians 4:4). Or there’s brother James, who begins his New Testament letter with an outrageous exhortation: "Whenever you face trials of any kind, consider it nothing but joy." (James 1:2).

Either these two apostles were deluded or something else is afoot. If you follow Jesus, you have a clue what it is. Or Who it is. For joy, spirit-given joy, is our resonance with the purposes of God. God breathed air into our nostrils and declared, “I want you to flourish. I want you to live abundantly.” When that breath circulates around, we can be revived. And we will be reminded that it is God who gives life, light, and hope to the world. This is the essence of joy.

One of the apostles of joy was a Dutch priest named Henri Nouwen. A talented man, able to stir the hearts of many, yet nagged by the recurring demon of depression. Here is something he offered, in a moment of spiritual clarity:

Joyful persons do not necessarily make jokes, laugh, or even smile. They are not people with an optimistic outlook on life who always relativize the seriousness of a moment or an event. No, joyful persons see with open eyes the hard reality of human existence and at the same time are not imprisoned by it. They have no illusion about the evil powers that roam around, “looking for someone to devour” (1 Peter 5:8), but they also know that death has no final power. They suffer with those who suffer, yet they do not hold on to suffering; they point beyond it to an everlasting peace.[1]

“Joy Inside My Tears,” indeed.

And so Jesus climbs the mountain with Peter, James, and John. While he is praying, he suddenly bursts into glory. He shines like the sun. Peter, James, and John rub the stardust out of their eyes. And who’s that? It’s Moses – they’ve never seen Moses before, but they can tell who he is. And Elijah, the greatest of the prophets, who once called down fire from heaven – he’s talking with Jesus, who glimmers like the sun on earth.

What are they talking about? Luke says they are talking about “his departure.” What do you mean, “his departure”? Well, the Greek word is “exodus.” They are discussing his exodus, his splitting open of the water, his leading of the people through the sea. You can guess what this exodus is because it’s going to happen at Passover time. Moses the lawgiver and Elijah the prophet testify to the death and resurrection of Jesus. That is his “departure,” his life-giving, life-saving “exodus.”

In a burst of glory, precipitated by prayer, Jesus discusses his death with two of the greatest figures in Jewish history. He’s discussing his death – while shining like the sun. What a strange paradox! And then I remembered an odd little verse in the letter to the Hebrews, where the writer of Hebrews declares Christ endured the cross "for the sake of the joy that was set before him." (12:2).

Joy? In the face of crucifixion? Yes, because it’s joy, that hidden confidence that God is alive and working out the eternal purposes. When that confidence comes, when those purposes are assured, they stand taller than anything that stands against us.

I think of three vignettes.

(1)   My friend Todd and his wife brought a baby boy into the world three years ago. They named him Rowan, nicknamed him “Baby Rowboat” from the sounds that he made. Six months after his birth, the doctors said he needed a liver transplant. It scared them to death. But Baby Rowboat smiled, giggled, made his rowboat sounds. They flew across the country for the procedure, back to their home in Dallas, back to Pittsburgh. Todd sent me a picture just the other day – Rowboat’s three years old and drinking a chocolate shake. Actually, he’s wearing a lot of the chocolate shake. He’s been through a lot, and he’s going to keep going. That’s what joy looks like.

(2)   And then I saw the photo of the young woman. She is decked out in her traditional Ukrainian outfit, red piping, elaborate embroidery, an ornate crucifix on a gold chain around her neck. Ever see an outfit like that? But it’s the look on her that face tells us everything. She’s standing tall, having lived through more heartbreak than any of us have ever seen. Her fierce eyes announce she is proud of her family, proud of her townspeople, proud of the way they endure through suffering. No tin-pot dictator will ever prevail over her. She is driven by joy.

(3)   And then, there’s this music, forged by creative souls out of deprivation, racism, and poverty. One of the earliest practitioners was a cornet player named Bix Beiderbecke. He was baptized in the Presbyterian church where his mother played the organ, and his father had the account for delivering coal. Bix took to music early, able to discover melodies on the piano when he was two years old.

But his parents never approved of the music he played, or where the jazz took him, or the national acclaim he received. The crowds cheered, but he was lost to his family. Life was painful, traveling was lonely. As he discovered the hard way, he could not patch a broken heart with bathtub gin. There were too many leaks.

Yet he could play his horn. Even when life looked dark, he could lean back, close his eyes, and blow love notes into the air. Shortly before he died at the early age of 28, Bix lived in a rooming house in Queens. He picked up his cornet at all hours of day and night and play his horn. The tenants in the building gently mentioned to the landlord that they had been awakened at three in the morning by lovely music coming out of that apartment. Then they quickly added, "Please don't mention we said anything; we don't want him to get in trouble, and we also don't want him to stop."[2] 

How could Beiderbecke blow such beauty into the air when life was so painful? You know the answer: it wasn’t happiness. It was joy.

There is more to be said because these things are mysteries, and as mysteries, they are elusive. Suffice it to say that joy is what carries us through to another new day. It is the engine of the soul. It sustains us through impossible difficulties. Joy is what pushes us forward until we, too, shine like the sun. This is inexplicable. And it is real.

As Jesus said, “Take heart, little flock. It is God's desire to give you the kingdom.” This is God's desire – and this is God's joy

 

(c) William G. Carter

[2] Richard M. Sudhalter and Philip R. Evans, Bix: Man & Legend (New Rochelle, NY: Arlington House Publishers, 1974) 327

Saturday, February 19, 2022

A Word for Victims

Luke 6:27-38
February 20, 2022
Epiphany 7
William G. Carter

But I say to you that listen, Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you. If anyone strikes you on the cheek, offer the other also; and from anyone who takes away your coat do not withhold even your shirt. Give to everyone who begs from you; and if anyone takes away your goods, do not ask for them again. Do to others as you would have them do to you. 

 

“If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners love those who love them. If you do good to those who do good to you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners do the same. If you lend to those from whom you hope to receive, what credit is that to you? Even sinners lend to sinners, to receive as much again. But love your enemies, do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return. Your reward will be great, and you will be children of the Most High; for he is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked. Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.

 

If anyone was disturbed by last week’s blessings and woes, here is some teaching that goes even further. Love your enemies. Do good to those who hate you. Bless those who curse you. Pray for those who abuse you. We hear Jesus say all of these things. It’s no wonder that somebody wanted to kill him.

These are among the most extreme teachings that he imparts, far more extreme than the average person is willing to go. I don’t know if you have any enemies. If so, I will venture a guess that you don’t actively love them. The best any of us could do is to ignore them, to give them room to live on the same planet, but pray that they don’t come too close.

Say, for instance, you have been elected to the local school board. One night when you have a quiet agenda, an angry parent stomps in the door. She is ready to attack you for policy decisions that your board has taken. To focus her fury, she singles you out, points, begins to accuse, calls you names, declares you are stupid, and then concludes the speech by quoting Bible verses. I will bet today’s offering plate she is not quoting these Bible verses. I’ll also bet you won’t be thinking of them.

So what might you do? How would you respond? There are plenty of options. You could start yelling at her and call her names. You could dial up the police. You could sit quietly and think of a logical rebuttal. Or you could do what a lot of folks I respect would do: listen as patiently as possible to her pain, hold your tongue, pray for a clear head, wait until she’s done, and then say something like, “Thank you for sharing your opinion.” Nobody wants to inflame an explosive situation. So you take the high road. Go home to sip the Maalox.

We don’t know what to do with enemies. If we could, we would prefer a quiet life, surrounded by those whom we enjoy. Preferably people a lot like us, who see the world from a similar perspective. These days, such folks are harder and harder to find.

That may be the rule, rather than the exception. Ever notice how the Bible is full of enemies? Why, just to take one test case, there are seventy-seven times in the Book of Psalms when the Poet mentions his enemies. Sometimes he describes how they bully him. Other times he complains, “Why doesn’t get rid of them?” Often he simply moans, “How long must I endure my enemies?”

Notice, however, he never declares any love for them. And if he prays for them, he prays they be scattered to the winds or destroyed. Jesus knew the Psalms. He prayed the Psalms. But here, he says, “Love the people who hate you.” What a radical thing to say!

Of course, he had some experience with this. We heard a couple of weeks ago about that first sermon in the hometown congregation. Their smiles turned to snarls. And they tried to throw him off a cliff. Ever since, just as he has collected followers and healed the sick, he has made a lot of enemies – and it’s only chapter six.

·         The demon in Capernaum said, “Jesus, what are you doing here? Leave us alone.”

·         Then he put his hand on a leper; he wasn’t supposed to do that.

·         He leaned over a paralyzed man and said, “Your sins are forgiven.” The religious people said, “Who do you think you are?”

·         Then he called out a tax collector and said, “Follow me.” The man left his job, which was a good thing, but then hosted Jesus for a banquet in his home, and that became a bad thing.

Oh yes, Jesus has been making a lot of enemies. We probably should expect that. In Luke’s stories of his childhood, there’s no Evil King Herod; he’s lurking over in the Gospel of Matthew. But there is an old man named Simeon, hanging around the temple, peeking into all the blue blankets, and asking, “Is this the One?” When he sees Baby Jesus, he scooped him up in his arms, blessed the child, blessed God – and then said to the mother, “This one will make others rise and fall; and he will be opposed.” Well, thanks for nothing, Old Man Simeon. You have announced his destiny before he’s weaned from his mother.

Life is not only full of conflict. Life is conflict. I hate to bring that up, but it’s true. And I’m not referring to the aggrieved politician who can’t process his own mistakes, nor the tyrant still fuming that his empire broke up thirty years ago. No, the conflicts come every day. Often the conflict sparks because we are trying to do the good thing, or at least the best we can.

I have a good friend, a pastor, who gets a long e-mail complaint every week from one of his absent church members. The guy is not even there, but he tunes in on YouTube, then writes a missive to complain about what he sees. Just to rub it in, he watches the online service one of those Glorious Churches with a large production staff, and then compares the Glorious Church with his own church, where he no longer attends. Grumble, grumble, grumble. Who needs it?

Yet I tell you, my friend reads every note, responds as positively as he is able, leaves his chainsaw at home, and encourages the Outraged Dude to pray, forgive, and keep tuning in. My buddy is a spiritual giant. Just like Jesus.    

If there is anything I have observed in the last five years of national poison (or is it the last twenty-five years of national poison), it is the regularity of conflict. We pray for peace because we have so little of it. And we know there’s no way to settle differences on a cable TV talk show. There is no lawsuit that can ever settle a score. Something else has to happen. And in saying that, we have a clue what it is.

Years ago, one of our elderly church members regularly sent me mail. No, he wasn’t complaining about me or any of you. He was lamenting about the world. Every time he saw something terrible in the newspaper, he clipped it and mailed it to me. Sometimes he saved them up. Once he sent a large manila envelope. Now why did he do that? Because he knew the world is a mess. Even here, in the manicured suburbs, there’s a lot of pain.

“So what do we do?” That’s what I asked him one day. “What do we do? You send me all these clippings of all these terrible things, what do we do?” He looked like I sprayed him with cold water on a February day.

“Well, you’re the expert,” he started to say. I cut him off and said, “I’m no expert. I don’t know very much at all.” That was another splash of cold water. So I said, “All I know is we have a very clear choice. Either we stay immobilized in pain, or we choose to step beyond it and find some way to express the love of God.”

That was more than he could handle, so he blurted out, “You’re probably going to tell me how Jesus says to love our enemies.” In a rare moment, God’s Spirit gave me enough moral clarity to say, “Bob, Jesus only commanded us to do what he was willing to do himself.” And that includes love our enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you.

The same Jesus who said such things is the One who forgave the people who put him on the cross. That’s how sin is cancelled, by forgiveness. That’s how brokenness is healed, by doing good. That’s how hate is extinguished, by love – generous, self-giving love. Just to prove it, Jesus came back after the cross to keep the movement going. And that’s why we are here.

Now you might think church is the place where enemies drop their weapons and people get along. After all, we talk a lot about forgiveness and mercy and grace. We talk a lot. We do a lot of talking…but talk can be cheap.

What I need to tell you is when Jesus speaks of love, he’s talking of active love. The word for love is “agape.” That is love that moves. Agape love comes from a place of power and moves to a place of service. Agape love comes from the heart of heaven and moves down here. Agape is what the apostle Paul is singing about in First Corinthians: patient, kind, never insisting on its own way, rejoicing in the truth. Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. It never ends, and it never sits still.

When Jesus says, “Love your enemies,” he is speaking to victims, to those who have had one cheek slapped, to those who have had their coats taken away from them. His word to them is not to merely stand there and take it, but to take the initiative and to counter hatred with love. That’s the ongoing task of those who follow Jesus. It’s the power of the word he speaks. On behalf of God, Jesus announces there’s another way to live, and it’s the way of acting for the benefit of other people. That’s the very definition of love.

 In a sermon called “Loving Our Enemies,” Martin Luther King Jr had these famous words to say:

 

Why should we love our enemies? The first reason is fairly obvious. Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that. Hate multiplies hate, violence multiplies violence, and toughness multiplies toughness in a descending spiral of destruction. So when Jesus says, “Love your enemies,” he is setting forth a profound and ultimately inescapable admonition… The chain reaction of evil (hate begetting hate, wars producing more wars) must be broken, or we shall be plunged into the dark abyss of annihilation.[1]

 Love is the only way forward. I gave some thought to how I might end the sermon today. But I couldn’t find a snappy saying or a heart-warming story. So I will simply affirm this kind of love is hard work. It’s soul work. We won’t achieve it with perfection, but we could improve with practice.

Today it’s enough to receive the words of Jesus and to remember how he begins to teach: “I say to those who listen: love, do good, bless, pray.” Anybody listening?



(c) William G Carter. All rights reserved.

[1] Martin Luther King Jr, “Loving Our Enemies,” The Strength to Love (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 2010) p. 47  

Saturday, February 12, 2022

The Great Reversal

Luke 6:17-26
Epiphany 6
February 13, 2022
William G. Carter  

Jesus came down with them and stood on a level place, with a great crowd of his disciples and a great multitude of people from all Judea, Jerusalem, and the coast of Tyre and Sidon. They had come to hear him and to be healed of their diseases; and those who were troubled with unclean spirits were cured. And all in the crowd were trying to touch him, for power came out from him and healed all of them.

Then he looked up at his disciples and said:
   “Blessed are you who are poor, for yours is the kingdom of God.
   “Blessed are you who are hungry now, for you will be filled.
   “Blessed are you who weep now, for you will laugh.
   “Blessed are you when people hate you, and when they exclude you, revile you, and defame you on account of the Son of Man. Rejoice in that day and leap for joy, for surely your reward is great in heaven; for that is what their ancestors did to the prophets.

“But woe to you who are rich, for you have received your consolation.
“Woe to you who are full now, for you will be hungry.
“Woe to you who are laughing now, for you will mourn and weep.
“Woe to you when all speak well of you, for that is what their ancestors did to the false prophets.”


Whenever I read the beatitudes of Jesus, somebody usually stops me at the door and says, “I don’t understand these.” A beatitude is a blessing, a verbal affirmation of divine favor, as in, “Blessed are you for showing up today in church.” At least one Bible scholar calls them “a heavenly congratulations.” Most of us can understand that.

The problem comes when we hear whom Jesus congratulates: the poor, the hungry, those who weep, those who are hated and despised because of Jesus. He may value them, but the world does not.

The world does have some people who lift up the poor, feed the hungry, lift the spirits of the sorrowful, and welcome those who the world rejects. But Jesus is not blessing the caregivers. He is congratulating those in need. That’s strange.

To make the waters muddier, he pronounces doom on those who have no pressing needs. Shame on you rich, you have what you need. Beware if your belly is full, you will starve. Watch out when you laugh, for you will cry. And woe to you if people admire you.

Does anybody understand all of this? Neither do I.

Maybe it will help if we switch to a happier text. Like the enhanced list of blessings in the Gospel of Matthew. They sound like these, kind of. Instead of “the poor,” Jesus blesses the poor in spirit. If anybody is feeling humble, they are blessed; I can almost understand it. And for those who grieve a great loss, there is the promise they will one day feel better, either here or on that final day when God makes everything right.

Of course, Matthew’s list is longer than Luke’s list. He blessed the meek, the pure in heart, the peacemakers – all worthy of some affirmation. And he doesn’t tack on that troublesome list of woes, at least not until 18 chapters later.

So does it help to hear there are other lists of blessings and woes? No, I didn’t think so.

Maybe it would help to lean back and take a broader perspective on the Gospel of Luke. Luke loves to upset the apple cart, turn it back up, and refill it with a different kind of fruit. He often reports Jesus as saying, “The first shall be last and … the last shall be first.” Long-established positions are reversed. Situations are flipped. This is how Luke and his church understand the coming of Jesus into the world. He will turn everything upside-down.

Remember what he will teach: the sinner is forgiven, the self-righteous religious man is condemned.[1] The wasteful son is welcomed home, the goody-two-shoes son is left standing out in the field.[2] Maybe Jesus picked this up from his mother, who sings before he is even born, “God has knocked the high and mighty off their thrones and lifted those who had somebody’s foot upon their heads. He has given a banquet to the hungry and sent the fat cats away with empty plates.”[3]

Does that sound revolutionary? You bet it does – because it’s in the Bible. We sang a portion of Mary’s song just two weeks ago, in a hymn written by a nun from New Jersey who traveled the world caring for the needy:

   The poor are rich, the weak are strong, the foolish ones are wise.
   Tell all who mourn, outcasts belong, who perishes will rise.[4]

Luke would have us know that God will not let injustice continue. He will not allow human pain to be unaddressed. Those who have climbed to riches on the backs of the underpaid are in for a big surprise. And those who have suffered will be relieved and released. That’s how the Bible talks. That’s what Jesus teaches. That’s what the people around Jesus are called to embody. We relieve suffering. We

Have you seen that CBS reboot of the old show, “The Equalizer”? If not, you can hear the plot in the name of the series. The church of the living Christ is called to be The Equalizer. Here is the community of faith where everybody is treated fairly. And if you don’t want that, woe to you.

Does that help to open up the text? Maybe, maybe not.

Where I call your attention is to the place where Jesus teaches these things. He doesn’t teach these beatitudes from a mountain. No, that list is different and came on a different day. Rather, he is speaking from “a level place.” A level place – I don’t know if Luke wants us to take that literally or not.

Right before this, Jesus went up to pray on a mountain. Now, it says he came down stood in a “level place.” There are plenty of flat places in Palestine, but it’s important for us to hear he stood with everybody. Not above them, but with them. The poor and the rich, the hungry and the full, those weeping and those laughing, those rejected and those affirmed. Both his feet were flat on the ground. That’s the word Luke uses.

It reminds me of what my friend Charles learned about himself. As a fresh new Baptist preacher, he came home exhausted and slept all Sunday afternoon. One day, he realized he preached on the balls of his feet and pointed down at the people. It was easier to wag his finger from up there. But when he stood flat-footed, as one human among others, he was refreshed and didn’t need a nap. He wasn’t lecturing. He was sharing, and it made all the difference.

So here is Jesus, the Equalizer, flat on his feet, fresh from a full day of preaching and healing. And what is he doing? He is sharing what he sees. He sees that everybody becomes hungry, both those who have no food and those who do. He perceives human feelings are taken seriously, but they are not permanent. Those weeping are capable of telling jokes (I’d heard some corkers at the funeral home). Those laughing now will cry tomorrow. That’s the see-saw of human emotion. Experience tends to level out.

And what does he see of the rich and the poor? Well, a lot of things. In this Gospel, Luke’s Gospel, Jesus speaks of wealth and possessions more than he speaks of the kingdom of God. In fact, he tells about someone who misses the kingdom because he owns too much stuff. That’s what he means when he says, “Woe to you rich!” You have everything you need – except for the one thing you need most. And he doesn’t tell us what that one thing is.

That’s the point of contact for me today. Two weeks ago, my mobile phone slipped out of my pocket. The screen had a little tiny chip. Because of that, the phone didn’t work. I could make calls from inside the car, but not whenever I wanted.

I took it to the store. Did I have insurance? No, it was a four-year-old phone. Well, you need a new phone; here’s a new flip phone for a thousand dollars. No, I don’t want a new phone. I want one that works.

A lot of you have been down this road. It’s a complete hassle for something that, not so long ago, you didn’t even possess. I mean, I’m old enough to remember when phones only made phone calls. Now your whole life is on that little device, that little device with the chipped screen that you can’t unlock any more. So I got a new phone. Not the fanciest, not the newest, but more than I actually need.

This is what wealth – as expressed in possessions – can do to us. We are reduced to consumers. Our conversations are aborted at restaurants. We can always “be found.” Some folks were worried about covid vaccines putting chips in our shoulders? Come on, already have a chip in my pocket. It tells me the next three books I need to buy from Amazon. In the words of Jesus, “Woe to me, because I have so much.”

And when I hear Jesus speak from a level place, when I hear him teach the beatitudes and the woes, I’m brought into the realm of what’s truly valuable and what’s not. Here’s a hint: the phone is on the “not” list, the “woe” list.

If the phone episode was not enough, I subscribe to an e-mail newsletter that offers tips to simplify my life. That’s one of the keys – if I don’t “need” it, I won’t get it. Less to carry around or throw into a landfill, which is what the rich folks like us do, and the poor wish they could do. This week’s newsletter scored a bullseye. The topic was, “100 Things I’d Say to My 18-Year-Old Self.” Here are a few things on that list:

You can’t keep up with the Joneses. There are no Joneses.
Start saving when you’re young.
Don’t buy the crystal. You’ll never use it.
Just because it’s on sale doesn’t mean you need it.
Don’t be embarrassed by the hand-me-down 1977 Oldsmobile Omega. It’s a gift.
Retail therapy doesn’t work.
Don’t start collecting Precious Moments figurines.
Sell your used college textbooks because you’ll never look at the again.
You can enjoy a book without buying it. (Ouch! That one hurt.)
Life is less complicated with less stuff.

You get the point. I certainly do. The person with the most toys loses, and when he’s gone, his kids will fight over his stuff. Or in the words of Jesus, “Woe to you if you are rich.” And if that saying still bothers you, there is one proven way to become less rich; but I’m not going to tell you what it is.

Blessed are you. Woe to you. Congratulations to you. Shame on you. These are the words of a Man on level ground.

He puts his words into the air and watches to see what they do. Some of us might change our lives because of what we hear. Others might hear something and ponder what might be required of us. Still others find ourselves settled in our ways and look for happier Bible texts.

But I leave you with a scene that I’ve never been able to shake out of my soul. Back in the late ‘90’s, a small team from our church traveled to Haiti, the poorest nation in the Western hemisphere. We went to church with folks who sang their hearts out for three hours on a Sunday. Women and men ironed their clothes before undertaking everyday work. They held their heads high at work or play, and they asked about our families. And the joy, and the laughter, and the dancing, and the joking - when they have so little.

Here is what I have always wondered: why were so many so happy when so much was pressing against them? What has gotten into them?  Or perhaps the better question: Who has gotten into them?


(c) William G. Carter.  All rights reserved.  

[1] Luke 18:9-14

[2] Luke 15:11-32

[3] Luke 1:46-55

[4] Miriam Therese Winter, “O for a World,” Glory to God, hymn 372.

Saturday, February 5, 2022

Not Worthy But Wanted

Luke 5:1-11
Epiphany 5
February 6, 2022
William G. Carter  

Once while Jesus was standing beside the lake of Gennesaret, and the crowd was pressing in on him to hear the word of God, he saw two boats there at the shore of the lake; the fishermen had gone out of them and were washing their nets. He got into one of the boats, the one belonging to Simon, and asked him to put out a little way from the shore. Then he sat down and taught the crowds from the boat. 

When he had finished speaking, he said to Simon, “Put out into the deep water and let down your nets for a catch.” Simon answered, “Master, we have worked all night long but have caught nothing. Yet if you say so, I will let down the nets.” When they had done this, they caught so many fish that their nets were beginning to break. So they signaled their partners in the other boat to come and help them. And they came and filled both boats, so that they began to sink. 

But when Simon Peter saw it, he fell down at Jesus’ knees, saying, “Go away from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man!” For he and all who were with him were amazed at the catch of fish that they had taken; and so also were James and John, sons of Zebedee, who were partners with Simon. Then Jesus said to Simon, “Do not be afraid; from now on you will be catching people.” When they had brought their boats to shore, they left everything and followed him.

 

Baptized in the river, tempted in the wilderness, and threatened after his sermon in Nazareth, Jesus now stands by the lake of Gennesaret (which is called the Sea of Galilee). It is here that he calls his first disciples. He tells them, “From now on you will be catching people.”

Ever since I first heard the story in childhood, this has always been a captivating scene for me. Jesus walks along the shoreline, sees some fishermen, and says, “Come, follow me.” Immediately they drop everything, and they follow. That’s how we normally hear the story. That’s how the Gospel of Mark tells it (1:16-20). Mark stresses the immediacy of the response. Jesus calls, and Simon and the others don’t even think about it. Off they go.

By contrast, Luke tells us more. Apparently, there was a backstory, specifically a fishing story. Simon spent a long night fishing without success. As he pulls ashore and cleans his nets, Jesus steps into his boat. The teacher asks to go out a little way from shore. He wants to utilize the water as a natural amplifier as he teaches. And when the lesson is over, he says, “Let’s go out a little further.” That’s when the real lesson begins.

Simon complains when the teacher tells him to drop the nets in the water. “Listen,” he says, “I’ve been out here all night. I’ve haven’t caught a thing. The fish are avoiding me.”

Jesus looks at him. Waits. Smiles. Doesn’t say a thing. “Let down your net for a catch.” Reluctantly, Simon agrees. He will do it for the teacher. The net drops into the lake water. Suddenly there are so many fish, the boat begins to tip. They holler for help, and James and John push offshore to join them. And there are even more fish, hundreds of fish, jumping into the net. With every possible muscle, the men pull up the nets and both boats are filled with fish. Both boats start to sink. It’s all they can do to get them ashore.

So there’s a miracle catch. The abundance is stunning. And this is the moment for us to lean forward and pay attention. Simon Peter cries out, “Lord, get away from me.” Don’t miss what happens next: Jesus stays right there.

Those who have tuned in for last week’s episode can guess how this is going to turn out. The synagogue folks in Nazareth grabbed Jesus and tried to propel him from a cliff, but he wouldn’t go. Then he goes to the Capernaum synagogue, literally a stone’s throw from Simon’s fishing boat, and a crazy man in the sanctuary cries out, “Why don’t you leave us alone?” And Jesus doesn’t go anywhere.

So for the third time in a row that we hear somebody say, “Get away from me” (in this case, Simon Peter), we can predict he’s not going to go anywhere. He’s going to stay right there. And this is the moment upon which all of Simon Peter’s life will turn.

Was it the miracle? Certainly, there was a miracle – an incredible catch of fish. It’s not easily explained. It stretches the imagination. Jesus or God or whoever sent all those fish has just made Simon a wealthy man. Take a catch like that to market, and it will erase his debts, pay his Roman taxes, feed his family, with a lot left over. But Simon is not interested in the money. Take note he doesn’t say, “Lord, can we go fishing again tomorrow?” He’s not interested in monetizing this moment.

So was it the miracle? Not necessarily. Simon has already experienced a miracle. It happened immediately before this story. His mother-in-law had a high fever. She was really sick. So the neighbors in that close-knit town asked the Teacher to stop by her home after the synagogue. Just as Jesus drove out the craziness in that man in the congregation, Jesus drove out the fever and made her well. Every healing is a miracle.

But something happened in that moment on the lakeshore. Something equally profound and subtle. What was it? And then I came across a brief poem based on this Bible story, just two lines from the Polish poet Czeslaw Milosz. Listen to this poem, called “Abundant Catch” –

         On the shore fish toss in the stretched nets of Simon, James, and John.

  High above, swallows. Wings of butterflies. Cathedrals.[1]

Up until the concluding word, it’s a fishing story. An observation of nature: fish, swallows, butterflies. But when the poet says, “Cathedrals,” suddenly we see something more than the routines of nature and a fishing excursion. We see holiness. A cathedral on a seashore. An epiphany in the everyday. “Holy, Holy, Holy” in a fishing boat.

That’s what sends Simon to his knees. He perceives Jesus as something more than a wise teacher or a gifted healer. He is the Holy One of God, and he climbed into Simon’s boat. “Get away from me,” he says. “Go away, for I am a sinner.”

Apparently Simon Peter has not read the first couple of chapters of this Gospel of Luke where his story appears. In the second chapter of the book, God sends his angel to announce the coming of Jesus to a flock of shepherds, widely perceived as sinners because they allowed their flocks to graze on other people’s lands. The angel sings, “Unto you is born this day a Savior who is Christ the Lord.”

The shepherds weren’t asking for a Savior. The angel didn’t require the shepherds to clean up their act before announcing the news. No, holiness comes from God into the everyday. It is pure gift, an unexpected revelation. It comes regardless of how pure we are, or how pure somebody tells us we ought to be. Because the Gospel is not about our purity; it’s about God’s goodness, God’s holiness, God’s abundance regardless of our purity. And that is the essence of grace.

As Presbyterian Christians, we believe God has a good heart, which is what we mean by “grace.” Yet sometimes our wires have been tangled. Years ago, our spiritual ancestors kept the number of communion Sundays to a minimum. They didn’t want to merely give away the sacrament to anybody. They expected people to come only if they were penitent and in a temporary state of sinlessness. To dramatize it, they would require attendance to something called a Preparatory Service. The faithful would cower in the pews while the preacher reminded them at length of how bad they are. If they could endure this, they would be given a small token, a communion token, which would grant them admission to the quarterly or biannual service of communion. You could only come to the Table if you scrubbed up your soul.

And then somebody decided to read the Bible. Who sat at the Table when Jesus instituted the sacrament? Judas Iscariot, who sold him out. Simon Peter, who swung a sword to cut off a servant’s ear. The other ten disciples, all of whom ran away when he was arrested. Not a pure one in the bunch. Exactly!

As our church’s Directory for Worship teaches, “The opportunity to eat and drink with Christ is not a right bestowed upon the worthy, but a privilege given to the undeserving who come in faith, repentance, and love.” (W-3.0409). So, if like Simon Peter, if any of us cry out, “Get away from me, Lord; I’m not worthy,” we are missing the point. None of us are “worthy” of the grace of God, but all of us receive it. None of us are worthy, but all of us are wanted.

And this is the miracle far greater than a huge catch of fish.

It’s the miracle that we dramatize at the beginning of our Sunday worship services. We sing a big, fat, glorious opening hymn, like “Holy, Holy, Holy.” Reminded of the splendor of God, we recognize the shortness of our own stature. We see God’s light, and know it reveals our shadows. And that’s precisely why we confess our sins: because we have sung of the holy grace of God, because we have seen the Light that calls us out of our shadows. Every part of our spiritual life is a response to the love of God. God comes first.

Still feeling inadequate? Let me tell you a parable, as told by a surgeon. In his book Mortal Lessons, Dr. Richard Selzer tells about standing beside the bed of one of his patients. She is a young woman, somebody’s wife, and he has removed a cancerous tumor from her cheek. As it happened, some of the nerves in her face had to be severed to save her life. She will be OK, but her smile will be permanently twisted.

Dr. Selzer stands by as her husband comes to visit. They embrace, speak quietly, and then she asks her surgeon, “Will my mouth always be like this?”

“Yes,” he replies, “it will. It is because the nerve was cut.” She nods and is silent. But the young man smiles. Then he says, “I like it. It is kind of cute.” Selzer says,


All at once I know who he is. I understand and I lower my gaze. One is not bold in an encounter with a god. Unmindful, he bends to kiss her crooked mouth and I am so close I can see how he twists his own lips to accommodate hers, to show her that their kiss still works.[2]

If we are inclined to believe that we are not worthy to receive the holy love of God, know this: that in Jesus of Nazareth, God accommodates our weakness and offers to meet us where we are. This is the essence of grace. Not because we are worthy, but because we are wanted.

And if we welcome that grace, there are a lot of other people who need to be loved in the name of Jesus.



(c) William G. Carter.  All rights reserved.

[1] Czeslaw Milosz, “Abundant Catch (Luke 5:4-10),” in The Gospels in Our Own Image: An Anthology of Twentieth Century Poetry Based on Biblical Texts, ed. David Curzon (New York: Harcourt, 1995) 73-4.

[2] Richard Selzer, M.D., Mortal Lessons: Notes on the Art of Surgery (New York: Simon and Shuster, 1978), pp. 45-46.